Reported Decisions of Reeves Richarz LLP Lawyers

Taking a case to a hearing, whether it be a motion, arbitration or trial is always expensive and always risky. We do our best to reduce expenses and mitigate that risk for our clients through negotiated resolutions. Sometimes, however, a negotiated settlement is not possible and a hearing is required. When that time comes, we are ready.

The lawyers at Reeves Richarz LLP have extensive in-court experience in a wide range of matters including insurance-related property, subrogation and coverage matters, first and third-party injury litigation as well as commercial litigation, family, estates and mortgage remedies actions.

Our decisions are noted below.

NameDateLawyerType
Jevco v. Chieftain, 2016March 11, 2016Mauro D’Agostino >Award  View Decision Document
Arnel Saqui v. Allstate Insurance Company of CanadaJanuary 13, 1997Gerald S. George >Appeal Order  View Decision Document
Virgini Mubarak v. General Accident Assurance Company of CanadaJanuary 19, 1996Neil Colville-Reeves >Decision  View Decision Document
Blair Stephens v. Zurich Insurance CompanyAugust 25, 1997Neil Colville-Reeves >Decision  View Decision Document
Cyril Morgan v. Allstate Insurance Company of CanadaMay 26, 1997Gerald S. George >Decision on a Preliminary Issue  View Decision Document
Felix Asiama v. Commercial Union Assurance CompanyMarch 31, 1998Neil Colville-Reeves >Decision on a Preliminary Issue  View Decision Document
Esterina Reda v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance CompanyJanuary 20, 1998Neil Colville-Reeves >Decision  View Decision Document
Irene B. Cook v. CAA Insurance Company (Ontario)September 6, 2001Neil Colville-Reeves >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Steven Howard Stelzer v. Zurich Insurance CompanyAugust 17, 2000Neil Colville-Reeves >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Henry Shedletzky v. Unifund Assurance CompanyMarch 26, 1999Gerald S. George >Decision on Expenses  View Decision Document
Annabel Antony v. RBC General Insurance Company, 2003 ON84May 26, 2003Mauro D’Agostino >Decision on a Third Party Preliminary Issue  View Decision Document
Annabel Antony v. RBC General Insurance Company, 2003 ON37March 12, 2003Mauro D’Agostino >Decision on a Preliminary Issue  View Decision Document
RBC General Insurance Company v. Annabel AntonyJuly 22, 2004Neil Colville-Reeves >Appeal Order  View Decision Document
Xuan Van Le v. Economical Mutual Insurance CompanyApril 19, 2004Neil Colville-Reeves >Assessment of Expenses  View Decision Document
Elliott v. BrownNovember 19, 2004Mauro D’Agostino >Endorsement  View Decision Document
Ziba Miri-Lashkajani v. RBC General Insurance CompanyOctober 27, 2004Neil Colville-Reeves >Decision on a Preliminary Matter  View Decision Document
Maria Onyszkiewicz v. Economical Mutual Insurance CompanyNovember 10, 2006Neil Colville-Reeves >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Mohammad Umer v. Unifund Assurance CompanySeptember 7, 2006Mauro D’Agostino >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Annabel Antony v. RBC General Insurance CompanyJanuary 23, 2006Neil Colville-Reeves >Decision on Expenses  View Decision Document
Mohamed Mansouri v. CAA Insurance Company (Ontario)January 24, 2007Neil Colville-Reeves >Decision on a Motion  View Decision Document
Gianfranco Marazita v. RBC General Insurance Company, 2006November 15, 2006Neil Colville-Reeves >Decision on a Preliminary Issue  View Decision Document
Janarthanan Tharmaratnam v. CAA Insurance Company (Ontario)March 1, 2007Mauro D’Agostino >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Gianfranco Marazita v. RBC General Insurance Company, 2007May 7, 2007Neil Colville-Reeves >Decision on Expenses  View Decision Document
Abdul Zaher Wahidpur v. Unifund Assurance CompanyJune 28, 2007Mauro D’Agostino >Pre-Hearing Decision  View Decision Document
Piratheep Ponnampalam v. RBC General Insurance Company, 2007June 8, 2007Neil Colville-Reeves >Decision on a Motion for Leave to Amend a Response to an Application for Arbitration  View Decision Document
Lisa Faiz v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company, 2007, ON167August 31, 2007Neil Colville-Reeves >Decision on a Preliminary Issue  View Decision Document
Piratheep Ponnampalam v. RBC General Insurance Company, 2008January 25, 2008Neil Colville-Reeves >Decision on a Preliminary Issue  View Decision Document
Lisa Faiz v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company, 2007, ON260December 28, 2007Neil Colville-Reeves >Decision on Expenses  View Decision Document
Abdul Zaher Wahidpur v. Unifund Assurance Company, 2008 ON55April 2, 2008Mauro D’Agostino >Decision on a Preliminary Issue  View Decision Document
Lisa Faiz v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company, 2008May 27, 2008Neil Colville-Reeves >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Economical Mutual Insurance Company v. Maria OnyszkiewiczApril 29, 2008Neil Colville-Reeves >Appeal Order  View Decision Document
Abdul Zaher Wahidpur v. Unifund Assurance Company, 2008 ON85May 28, 2008Mauro D’Agostino >Appeal Order  View Decision Document
Guido Poblete v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance CompanyJune 18, 2009Neil Colville-Reeves >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Primmum Insurance Company v. Allstate Insurance CompanyNovember 10, 2010Gerald S. George >Judgement  View Decision Document
Lilia Kadosh (The Estate of) v. Economical Mutual Insurance CompanyJuly 27, 2010Neil Colville-Reeves >Motion Decision  View Decision Document
The Estate of Lilia Kadosh v. Economical Mutual Insurance CompanyDecember 23, 2010Neil Colville-Reeves >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Royal Bank v. TrangJune 6, 2012Justin Winch >Reasons for Judgement  View Decision Document
Reeve v. Pembridge Insurance CompanySeptember 26, 2011Ryan Kirshenblatt >Reasons for Judgement  View Decision Document
Royal Bank of Canada v. Trang, 2012December 21, 2012Justin Winch >Court of Appeal Endorsement  View Decision Document
Gina Palozzi v. Economical Mutual Insurance CompanyJuly 9, 2012Ryan Kirshenblatt >Pre-Hearing Decision  View Decision Document
Vaneswaran Varatharjah v. Pafco Insurance CompanyJanuary 10, 2013Ryan Kirshenblatt >Motion to Dismiss  View Decision Document
Economical Insurance Co. v. Fariview Assessment CentreJune 7, 2013Ryan Kirshenblatt >Endorsement  View Decision Document
Mullin v. AllstateJune 7, 2013Ryan Kirshenblatt >Corrected Decision on Motion  View Decision Document
Paulena Victor Joseph v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance CompanyOctober 29, 2013Ryan Kirshenblatt >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Eliana Anton v. Economical Mutual Insurance CompanyDecember 2, 2013Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision on a Preliminary Issue  View Decision Document
Mirko Stojanov v. Dominion of Canada General Insurance CompanyNovember 14, 2013Neil Colville-Reeves >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Royal Bank of Canada v. Trang, 2014December 9, 2014Justin Winch >Case Summary  View Decision Document
Wilson v Scotia Mortgage Corporation, 2017February 24, 2014Neil Colville-Reeves >Costs Endorsement  View Decision Document
Hill v. Scotia Mortgage CorporationMarch 5, 2015Justin Winch >Endorsement  View Decision Document
Frank Banos v. Jevco Insurance CompanyAugust 31, 2015Ryan Kirshenblatt >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Dufferin Construction v The Dominion of CanadaAugust 19, 2015Neil Colville-Reeves >Reasons for Judgement  View Decision Document
Sipsas v 1299781 Ontario Inc., 2016February 3, 2016Justin Winch >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Dufferin Construction Company Inc. v The Dominion of Canada General Insurance CompanyFebruary 19, 2016Neil Colville-Reeves >Costs Endorsement  View Decision Document
Patrick Matthews v. Dumfries Mutual Insurance Company, 2016September 29, 2016Neil Colville-Reeves >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Giuseppe Terranova v. Economical Mutual Insurance Company, 2016April 1, 2016Neil Colville-Reeves >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Wilson v Scotia Mortgage Corporation, 2016December 23, 2016Neil Colville-Reeves >Supplementary Endorsement  View Decision Document
Wilson v Scotia Mortgage Corporation et al.November 14, 2016Neil Colville-Reeves >Endorsement  View Decision Document
Belairdirect Insurance v Dominion of Canada General Insurance CompanyJanuary 16, 2017Neil Colville-Reeves >Reasons for Judgement  View Decision Document
Sipsas v. 1299781 Ontario Inc., 2017March 31, 2017Justin Winch >Appeal  View Decision Document
16-000151 v Allstate Insurance Company of CanadaFebruary 3, 2017Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision  View Decision Document
Mohammed Niyas v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance CompanyMay 17, 2017Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision on a Preliminary Issue  View Decision Document
Qamar Abdullahi v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance CompanyJune 12, 2017Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision on a Preliminary Issue  View Decision Document
Joseph Garofalo v. Economical Mutual Insurance CompanyJune 12, 2017Neil Colville-Reeves >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
(Jan) Wakeel Ahmed v. Allstate Insurance Company of CanadaJune 19, 2017Ryan Kirshenblatt >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Khai-Tuong Hoang v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance CompanyJune 12, 2017Mauro D’Agostino >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Parker Pad & Printing Ltd. v. Gore Mutual Insurance CompanyJune 26, 2017Justin Winch >Case Summary  View Decision Document
16-004212 v Allstate Insurance Company of CanadaNovember 10, 2017Ryan Kirshenblatt >Reasons for Decision and Order  View Decision Document
Patrick Matthews v. Dumfries Mutual Insurance Company, 2017July 12, 2017Neil Colville-Reeves >Appeal Order  View Decision Document
Zi Feng Zhang v. Pembridge Insurance Company, 2017December 18, 2017Ryan Kirshenblatt >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Giuseppe Terranova v. Economical Mutual Insurance Company, 2017December 5, 2017Neil Colville-Reeves >Appeal Order  View Decision Document
17-000480AABS v PAFCOJanuary 15, 2018Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision  View Decision Document
L.J. v Allstate Insurance CompanyMay 27, 2019Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision  View Decision Document
Zi Feng Zhang v. Pembridge Insurance Company, 2018 ONFSCDRS 77April 17, 2018Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision on Expenses  View Decision Document
18-003343 v Intact Insurance CompanyJune 12, 2019Gerald S. George >Preliminary Issue Decision and Order  View Decision Document
Z.B. vs. Pafco Insurance CompanyJuly 26, 2019Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision  View Decision Document
O.T. v. Allstate CanadaJuly 18, 2019Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision  View Decision Document
P.V. v Economical Insurance, 2019September 13, 2019Gerald S. George >Preliminary Issue Descision  View Decision Document
C.B. v Allstate Insurance Company of Canada, 2019August 16, 2019Ryan Kirshenblatt >Motion Decision  View Decision Document
R.C. v Economical Insurance CompanyNovember 5, 2019Gerald S. George >Reconsideration Decision  View Decision Document
S.H.S.K. v. Allstate CanadaSeptember 16, 2019Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision and Order  View Decision Document
Galea v. Best Water LimitedDecember 11, 2019Jaime M. Naumis >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
J.P. v Allstate Insurance CompanyJanuary 9, 2020Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision  View Decision Document
P.V. and Economical Insurance, 2020January 24, 2020Gerald S. George >Reconsideration Decision  View Decision Document
Aviva Insurance Company of Canada v. Allstate Insurance Company of CanadaJanuary 31, 2020Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision  View Decision Document
P.S. v Allstate InsuranceSeptember 28, 2020Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision  View Decision Document
C.B. v Allstate Insurance Company of Canada, 2020August 20, 2020Ryan Kirshenblatt >Motion Order  View Decision Document
C.B. v Allstate Insurance Company of Canada, 2021January 27, 2021Ryan Kirshenblatt >Motion Order  View Decision Document
Siow v. Allstate Insurance Company of CanadaApril 22, 2021Jaime M. Naumis >Decision  View Decision Document
Loukas v. Imperial Oil LimitedMarch 15, 2021Neil Colville-Reeves >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Acamovic v. Cayuga Mutual Insurance CompanyOctober 18, 2021Gerald S. George >Reconsideration Decision  View Decision Document
Cafaro v. AlloulJune 22, 2021Ryan Kirshenblatt >Endorsement  View Decision Document
Smektala v TD Insurance Meloche MonnexOctober 29, 2021Gerald S. George >Preliminary Issue Descision  View Decision Document
Jarvis v QuinnMarch 15, 2022Christopher Zhao >Decision and Reasons  View Decision Document
Fard v Economical InsuranceFebruary 9, 2022Ryan Kirshenblatt >Preliminary Issue Decision  View Decision Document
Friedlander v. York Condominium Corporation No. 427, ONCAT 27April 5, 2022Friedlander v. York Condominium Corporation No. 427, ONCAT 27 >Motion Decision  View Decision Document
Lin v Pembridge Insurance CompanyJuly 8, 2022Jaime M. Naumis >Decision  View Decision Document
Friedlander v. York Condominium Corporation No. 427, ONCAT 67June 17, 2022Friedlander v. York Condominium Corporation No. 427, ONCAT 67 >Motion Order  View Decision Document
Sigma Convector Enclosure Corp. v. Fluid Hose & Coupling Inc., 2022 ON4371July 26, 2022Sigma Convector Enclosure Corp. v. Fluid Hose & Coupling Inc., 2022 ON4371 >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Sigma Convector Enclosure Corp. v. Fluid Hose & Coupling Inc., 2022 ON5633October 4, 2022Sigma Convector Enclosure Corp. v. Fluid Hose & Coupling Inc., 2022 ON5633 >File Direction  View Decision Document
Ferlisi v Allstate Insurance Company of CanadaSeptember 6, 2022Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision  View Decision Document
Friedlander v. York Condominium Corporation No. 427, ONCAT 110October 12, 2022Friedlander v. York Condominium Corporation No. 427, ONCAT 110 >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Allen v. Gerstel, 2022November 3, 2022Neil Colville-Reeves >Reasons for Decision on Toronto Star Request to Record Proceedings  View Decision Document
Iravani-Fard v Economical InsuranceNovember 17, 2022Ryan Kirshenblatt >Reconsideration Decision  View Decision Document
Tyulyakov v Allstate Insurance Company of CanadaDecember 14, 2022Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision and Order  View Decision Document
Russell v Dumfries Mutual Insurance CompanyJanuary 12, 2023Neil Colville-Reeves >Decision  View Decision Document
Allen v. Gerstel, 2023January 6, 2023Neil Colville-Reeves >Reasons for Decision  View Decision Document
Sapusak v. 9706151 Canada Ltd., ON197January 13, 2023Neil Colville-Reeves >Endorsement  View Decision Document
D’Mello v. Sapusak et al.February 8, 2023Jaime M. Naumis >Judgement  View Decision Document
Sapusak v. 9706151 Canada Ltd., ON196January 13, 2023Neil Colville-Reeves >Endorsement  View Decision Document
D’Mello v SapusakApril 21, 2023Neil Colville-Reeves >Endorsement  View Decision Document
Doyle v Pembridge Insurance CompanyJune 28, 2023Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision  View Decision Document
Allen v Esther Gerstel Inc.May 1, 2023Neil Colville-Reeves >Endorsement  View Decision Document
Cao v Allstate CanadaJuly 24, 2023Andrew Rodrigues >Preliminary Issue Decision and Order  View Decision Document
Troy Brunelle v. Jevco Insurance CompanyJuly 19, 2023Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision on a Preliminary Issue  View Decision Document
[G] v Allstate InsuranceSeptember 12, 2023Ryan Kirshenblatt >Amended Decision  View Decision Document
Ainanshe v Allstate InsuranceOctober 19, 2023Ryan Kirshenblatt >Decision  View Decision Document
Gur Prem Pyari Shillingford v. 9706151 Canada Ltd.November 6, 2023Neil Colville-Reeves >Endorsement  View Decision Document
Weber v Allstate Insurance, 2023October 27, 2023Ryan Kirshenblatt >Reconsideration Decision  View Decision Document
Sayeed Mohammed v Allstate InsuranceNovember 9, 2023Sayeed Mohammed v Allstate Insurance >Decision  View Decision Document
Vu v Pembridge InsuranceJanuary 4, 2024Jaime M. Naumis >Amended Decision  View Decision Document
Sapusak v. 9706151 Canada Ltd., ON6922December 15, 2023Neil Colville-Reeves >Endorsement  View Decision Document